Help - Search - Members - Calendar
Full Version: Should I Ditch The Hps Veg Light For Cfl?
UK420 > Cultivation > Growroom Design > Lighting
v6steve
I currently have a very small veg room (18"x24") which has a 250W HPS in it for vegging and will eventually be used as a mother room.

Am I right in thinking that this could be replaced with a couple of 20W CFL lights which could then be used for rooting clones, supporting mothers and vegging... The best of all worlds!

If I just wanna a buy a CFL from B&Q or somewhere similar, how can I tell which CFL lights are blue spectrum and which are red spectrum?

Cheers
compostverte
Mothers and rooting clones - just bog standard £1 CFLs will do the trick.

For vegging you want to keep that HPS.
neothe1
funny i just bought 2 cfl's from B&Q today , look for the the 23 watt ones , they are the biggest i found, They are in a green box with energy saving tech on it ..These ones are rich in the blue spectrum . I use 2 of them plus 1 16 watt strip fluro for mums and babies . Works a treat for me although different strokes for different folks as they say yinyang.gif
compostverte
What I seem to have discovered with my 8 x 18 watt vegging light (18 watts per seedling) is it's nice and efficient for the first couple of weeks, but once the plant really starts growing, an intense light source 9 inches away hits more and more surface area. whereas the CFL 1 inch from the tops has to shine through the to top foliage to get to the lower leaves.

Because I'm a bit of an anorak, I may treat myself to a 70 watt HPS to see how they compare.

edit:-

looking at your Durban Skunk diary, I suspect you may be a bit timid with light intensities. In my experience you need to get the lights as close as possible.

[attachmentid=127661]

18 days from sowing the seeds directly into the compost.


v6steve
£1...!!!

Awesome, now thats the sort of expense I can handle!!

Will it benefit me to put a couple of these in my flower room with my 600W HPS?
I heard that some blue spectrum light can increase the strength of the bud!!

Would I need loads of CFL's, so that they aren't completely over powered by the HPS?
compostverte
I wouldn't bother adding fluorescent to HID - probably cause more trouble than they're worth.

My preference is one of these for mothers / cuttings :-

[attachmentid=127662]

(apologies for dying plants whistling.gif - I really should get a better photo.)

How high do you keep the 600 watt lamp above the plants ?
neothe1
QUOTE(compostverte @ Feb 13 2007, 08:16 PM) [snapback]857233[/snapback]

I wouldn't bother adding fluorescent to HID - probably cause more trouble than they're worth.

My preference is one of these for mothers / cuttings :-

[attachmentid=127662]

(apologies for dying plants whistling.gif - I really should get a better photo.)

How high do you keep the 600 watt lamp above the plants ?



what happened to those ladies ???????? 34.gif
v6steve
The 600W is about 2ft above the plants at the moment.

Is this too high?
compostverte
QUOTE(neothe1 @ Feb 13 2007, 08:53 PM) [snapback]857263[/snapback]

what happened to those ladies ???????? 34.gif

They were reveggings done under my HPS lights - I changed my mind about keeping them around about when the photo was taken. whistling.gif
compostverte
QUOTE(v6steve @ Feb 13 2007, 09:12 PM) [snapback]857293[/snapback]

The 600W is about 2ft above the plants at the moment.

Is this too high?

Nope - sounds fine according to the lighting efficiency sticky. And it's a balance between intensity and coverage in any case.

Looking at your space - it's like mine - a bit on the wide side ...
The_Embalmer
HID lighting rule in my enviro. Vegging and Flowering.

No reason whatsoever to use florries or change something that I know works for my projects and set-up.
This is a "lo-fi" version of our main content. To view the full version with more information, formatting and images, please click here.
Invision Power Board © 2001-2010 Invision Power Services, Inc.